FORT DODGE — It’s hard to beat a team five times in a row. That was the task that the Durant Wildcat softball team had before them last Thursday in the class 2A semifinals in Fort Dodge. Waiting for them was RVC rival Iowa City Regina a team they have beaten four times in a row in conference play and seven times in their last 10 regular season games going back to the 2013 season. The Wildcats own a 6-2 record in RVC play against the Regals. The two teams have combined to win three state championships in a five-year span from 2011-2015 and are arguably consistent powers in class 2A. However, the Regals were the team that took advantage of mistakes and got just enough offense to get past Durant, 2-1 in the semifinal. The Wildcats were seeking a berth in the 2A championship for the first time since 2013.
“They didn’t beat us, we beat ourselves,” Durant softball coach Steve Hopkins said. “We outplayed them in every facet of the game except the score, and unfortunately that doesn’t count.
"We’re swinging at pitches outside of the zone and watching strikes go by. All facets of the game we didn’t do the way we’ve been able to that got us to this point. It’s disappointing because we’re better than that,” said Hopkins.
The Regals were at state for the sixth time in school history and making their fourth state trip in five years. Regina won the 2A title in 2011 and 2015 and were runners-up last summer. Regina was led by three 2016 All-Tournament team selections pitcher Sarah Lehman, leftfielder Emma Corkery and first baseman Katie Bracken. Lehman was the captain of the all-tournament team in 2015. Regals head coach Jon Prottsman topped the 250-win mark as the Regals coach this past summer.
Durant was making their fifth state trip in six years and sixth in program history. Durant won the state title in 2013. Head coach Steve Hopkins won his 300th game in the Wildcats 10-0 win over North Cedar in regional play.
Iowa City Regina got on the scoreboard first with a run in the first inning. Lead off batter Emily Bonnett was hit by a pitch on the third pitch of the game. Meyer struck out Corkery for the first out and Jess Hunter for the second out. Sarah Lehman was hit by a pitch, giving Regina their second baserunner. Katie Bracken then hit a shot to Wildcat second baseman Aubrey Werthmann who had trouble fielding it and the ball squirted away allowing Bonnett to score from second for a 1-0 lead. Meyer got Taylor O’Conner to flyout but the Regals led 1-0.
Durant was in position to tie the game in the bottom of the first inning. Ruby Kappeler led off with a single and advanced to second on a Hannah Happ ground out. Kappeler stole third to get one base away from scoring with one out. Aubrey Werthmann then tried to get a bunt down on a squeeze play and missed, and Kappeler was caught stealing for the second out. Werthmann struck out on the next pitch, ending the inning.
Durant had their best scoring chance in the third inning when they had two runners on base and one out with Kira Schult at second and Ruby Kappeler at first. Regina then got Hannah Happ to fly out and Lehman got Aubrey Werthman out on strikes. The Wildcats had runners at second base in the second and fourth innings too, but could not push the tying run across the plate.
Regina added another run in the top of the sixth inning. Jess Hunter walked and went to second on a one-out ground out by Bracken. Hunter then scored on a single by O’Conner to give Regina a 2-0 lead going to the bottom of the sixth.
Durant broke through in the bottom of the sixth. Werthmann tripled to lead off the inning and after a Cathy Ralfs fly out, scored on a fielder’s choice by Kamryn Meyer to set the score at 2-1 Regals.
Meyer mowed down the Regals in the top of the seventh, striking out two and getting a weakly hit ground out, to give the Wildcats a chance in the bottom of the inning. There, Lehman got Mallory Warner to pop out on the first pitch of the inning and Regal centerfielder Jess Hunter made a fantastic play on a line-drive by Kira Schult to get the second out of the inning. Lehman ended the game with her eighth strikeout as Ruby Kappeler went down on strikes.
Hopkins said that his team just couldn’t get a big hit when they needed it.
“We just couldn’t get that big hit we needed once we got someone in scoring position,” Hopkins said. “The softball gods just weren’t looking out for us today. We were just one hit away from turning it around. It just didn’t seem like we could build any momentum,” he said.
Durant outhit the Regals in the game 5 to 2 in the ball game, but only had one inning where they had more than one hit in the inning. Ruby Kappeler was 2-for-4 and Aubrey Werthmann, Cathy Ralfs and Kira Schult each had hits in the game.
Kamryn Meyer took the loss despite pitching well. Meyer worked all seven innings and allowed only two hits. She struck out ten Regal batters and walked two.
Regina’s hits came from singles from Sarah Lehman and Taylor O’Conner. Meyer kept the Regals first three hitters in the order down in the game. Regal lead off batter Emily Bonnett (.326 ave, 46 hits, .353 OBP), Emma Corkery (.367 ave., .376 OBP, 51 hits) and number three hitter Jess Hunter (.323 ave., .369 OBP, 42 hits) were a combined 1-for-7 with six strikeouts in the game.
Lehman matched Meyer’s effort with one of her own and pitched well for the Regals, working all seven innings. She struck out eight and walked one batter.
The Wildcats beat Lehman 2-1 at home in the regular season and Regina coach Jon Prottsmann thought for a moment that the game would be like that, as the Wildcats rallied in the sixth inning of that win.
“We were up one to nothing going to the sixth the first time we played and they got a double and a home run and beat us 2-1 so the sixth inning with their studs coming up I thought ‘we are up one run it’s the bottom of the sixth what’s going to happen here’,” Prottsman said. “This time she just bowed her neck a little bit and said, ‘nah not this time’,” he said.
“She was just better than they were, that’s all there is to it,” Prottsman said of Lehman. “And they are good, but she was better than they were.”